461 ratings
Old Nation Brewing
Williamston, United States
chevron_leftchevron_right
Is this your brewery?
Register your brewery for FREE and be in control how you are presented in Pint Please!
Register your breweryReviews
Sirdubby
@ Old Nation Brewing Company3 months ago
4.3
It's been a while since I've posted on here. How about a side by side by side review.
Old Nation has released 3 Creamsicle variants of M-43 and I happen to have a can (or more) of each. I've already had all three, but I'm curious to see which one I like the most.
Orange Creamsicle M-43
Raspberry Creamsicle M-43
Piña Colada Creamsicle M-43
O: Vibrant orange along with some light vanilla in the aroma. Taste has lots of oranges (and possibly orange peel) up front, followed by vanilla. Underneath this, the base M-43 is still detectable. Minor amount of bitterness in the finish.
R: Lots of raspberry along with more noticeable vanilla in the aroma. Taste has a delicious raspberry flavor along with some vanilla. Just like in the orange variant, the base M-43 is still there. Little to no bitterness in the finish.
PC: Pineapple is dominant, with coconut following and a tiny bit of vanilla in the aroma. Taste has pineapple and coconut right up front, followed by vanilla that definitely stands out more than it did in the aroma. The base M-43 is the most hidden in this one, but it's there. More bitterness in the finish than the other 2, but not a ton.
Despite the name, the body is no thicker than the base M-43, coming in somewhere between Medium+ and Medium-full. The carbonation is similar with all three being about medium-ish.
Honestly, I sort of knew which one I liked the best, but I wanted to confirm with the side by side by side. My opinion is slightly biased (I'm not a huge raspberry fan), but none are bad at all. Very well made and very tasty. I think the addition of lactose would set all three of these over the top, but they're fine as they are. My rankings are as follows:
#1: Orange Creamsicle M-43 4.5/5
#2: Piña Colada Creamsicle M-43 High 4.25/5
#3: Raspberry Creamsicle M-43 4.25/5
Cheers all!
Sirdubby
@ Old Nation Brewing Company3 months ago
4.3
It's been a while since I've posted on here. How about a side by side by side review.
Old Nation has released 3 Creamsicle variants of M-43 and I happen to have a can (or more) of each. I've already had all three, but I'm curious to see which one I like the most.
Orange Creamsicle M-43
Raspberry Creamsicle M-43
Piña Colada Creamsicle M-43
O: Vibrant orange along with some light vanilla in the aroma. Taste has lots of oranges (and possibly orange peel) up front, followed by vanilla. Underneath this, the base M-43 is still detectable. Minor amount of bitterness in the finish.
R: Lots of raspberry along with more noticeable vanilla in the aroma. Taste has a delicious raspberry flavor along with some vanilla. Just like in the orange variant, the base M-43 is still there. Little to no bitterness in the finish.
PC: Pineapple is dominant, with coconut following and a tiny bit of vanilla in the aroma. Taste has pineapple and coconut right up front, followed by vanilla that definitely stands out more than it did in the aroma. The base M-43 is the most hidden in this one, but it's there. More bitterness in the finish than the other 2, but not a ton.
Despite the name, the body is no thicker than the base M-43, coming in somewhere between Medium+ and Medium-full. The carbonation is similar with all three being about medium-ish.
Honestly, I sort of knew which one I liked the best, but I wanted to confirm with the side by side by side. My opinion is slightly biased (I'm not a huge raspberry fan), but none are bad at all. Very well made and very tasty. I think the addition of lactose would set all three of these over the top, but they're fine as they are. My rankings are as follows:
#1: Orange Creamsicle M-43 4.5/5
#2: Piña Colada Creamsicle M-43 High 4.25/5
#3: Raspberry Creamsicle M-43 4.25/5
Cheers all!
Sirdubby
@ Old Nation Brewing Company3 months ago
4.5
It's been a while since I've posted on here. How about a side by side by side review.
Old Nation has released 3 Creamsicle variants of M-43 and I happen to have a can (or more) of each. I've already had all three, but I'm curious to see which one I like the most.
Orange Creamsicle M-43
Raspberry Creamsicle M-43
Piña Colada Creamsicle M-43
O: Vibrant orange along with some light vanilla in the aroma. Taste has lots of oranges (and possibly orange peel) up front, followed by vanilla. Underneath this, the base M-43 is still detectable. Minor amount of bitterness in the finish.
R: Lots of raspberry along with more noticeable vanilla in the aroma. Taste has a delicious raspberry flavor along with some vanilla. Just like in the orange variant, the base M-43 is still there. Little to no bitterness in the finish.
PC: Pineapple is dominant, with coconut following and a tiny bit of vanilla in the aroma. Taste has pineapple and coconut right up front, followed by vanilla that definitely stands out more than it did in the aroma. The base M-43 is the most hidden in this one, but it's there. More bitterness in the finish than the other 2, but not a ton.
Despite the name, the body is no thicker than the base M-43, coming in somewhere between Medium+ and Medium-full. The carbonation is similar with all three being about medium-ish.
Honestly, I sort of knew which one I liked the best, but I wanted to confirm with the side by side by side. My opinion is slightly biased (I'm not a huge raspberry fan), but none are bad at all. Very well made and very tasty. I think the addition of lactose would set all three of these over the top, but they're fine as they are. My rankings are as follows:
#1: Orange Creamsicle M-43 4.5/5
#2: Piña Colada Creamsicle M-43 High 4.25/5
#3: Raspberry Creamsicle M-43 4.25/5
Cheers all!
Jonas M
@ ØK-Brew4 months ago
2.8
Henri
@ Restaurante Temantico5 months ago
4.4
Erfrischend gut
Clément R
@ La Grotte à Bières8 months ago
4.0
Changement d’endroit mais toujours dans le même style de bière.
Robe orangée, nez léger mais tirant sur la mangue/peche et ananas.
Au gout de l’acidité du citron. Texture juteuse, avec de la mangue et de l’ananas. Les 9 volts passent tranquillement.
David D
@ Bottle Mixx10 months ago
4.0
Mellowy goodness in an unassuming can. Guess you cant judge a beer by its label.